Withatur
petak, 18.10.2013.
Disagreements About Justice
They lived according to the principle of subjective perception, and thus cast a bad light on Socrates, for it is shown in this how the Socratic principle in another form brought about the ruin of Greek life. It may happen that at death, in illness and catalepsy, men know about circumstances future or present, which, in the understood relations of things, are altogether unknown. Nor does he who marries a wife know whether he will experience happiness or whether grief and sorrow will not come through this to him; neither can he who has powerful relations in the State, know whether, on account of these, he may not be banished from the State. Online Casinos for USA Players - No Deposit Bonus Wpt Poker who cultivates loner field does not know who will enjoy the fruit, nor does he who builds a house know who will inhabit it; the general does not know whether the army should be brought into the field; he who rules a State whether it is good for him” (the individual) “or bad. To hold the future, or what is foreseen by the somnambulist or at death to be a higher kind of insight, is a perversion which easily arises even in our ideas; but looked at more closely, we find in this the particular interests loner individuals merely, and the knowledge of what is right and moral is something much higher loner . Because of this uncertainty, men have to take refuge in divination. Thus it, was true that “the intercourse with his friends was, on. The general who had to fight a battle was guided in his decision by the entrails of animals, as we often find in Xenophon’s Anabasis. It loner the form of a knowledge which was directly loner with a condition of unconsciousness; it was a knowledge which may also appear under other conditions as a magnetic state. This element, the fact that the people had not the power of decision loner were determined from without, was a real factor in Greek consciousness; and oracles were everywhere essential where man did not yet know himself inwardly as being sufficiently free and independent to take upon himself to decide as we do. The Genius of Socrates is not Socrates himself, not his opinions and conviction, but an oracle which, however, is not Online Casinos for USA Players - 7RED Casino No Deposit Bonus but is subjective, bis oracle. Pausanias tormented himself thus a whole day long before he gave the command to fight. The general or the people did not take upon themselves to decide as loner what was best in the State, nor did the indi vidual do so in the family. This subjective freedom, which was not yet present with the Greeks, is what we mean in the present day when we speak of freedom; in the Platonic Republic we shall see more of it. But in them the Greeks, with all their freedom, did not decide from the subjective will. Thereby it certainly receives the stamp of imagination, but there is nothing more of what is visionary or superstitious to be seen in it. The education of the citizens, life in the people, is quite a fresh force in the individual, and does not mean that he educates himself through arguments; hence, however truly educative the intercourse with Socrates was, this contingency still entered into it. revealed to the individual only, and not as being what it is in truth. In connection with what follows, we must yet further consider the relationship of the Genius to the earlier existent form of decision, and that into which it led Socrates; regarding both Xenophon expresses himself in his history Online Casinos for USA Players - No Deposit Bonus US Welcome distinctly. We thus see as an unhappy symptom of disorder, how Socrates’ greatest favourites, and those endowed with the most genial loner (such as Alcibiades, that genius of levity, who played with the Athenian people, and Critias, the most active of the Thirty) afterwards experienced the fate of being judged in their own country, one as an enemy and traitor to his fellows, and the other as an oppressor and tyrant of the State. The Greeks loner not possess the knowledge of this infinitude. In the first book of Xenophon’s Memorabilia, on the occasion of the defence by Socrates of his daimonion, Socrates says at the very beginning: “The gods have reserved to themselves what is most important in knowledge. These are facts which loner usually rudely denied.
Oznake: philosophy
