14.01.2022., petak
Despite much evidence that getting lots of physical
|
Certain factors that make people more likely to have physically demanding jobs may also make them more apt to die young, said Silvia Stringhini, a researcher at the Institute of Social and Preventive Medicine and Lausanne University Hospital in Switzerland.But the idea that it might drive people to an early grave is relatively new, Coenen said."But the study found different results for women. Overall, 29,639 people, or 19 per cent, died during the study period. The study team also lacked data on other forms of exercise like commuting on foot or by bike.One limitation of the analysis is that most of the smaller studies relied on participants to accurately recall the amount and intensity of any physical activity on the job, researchers note in the British Journal of Sports Medicine. Trine Moholdt, a researcher at the Norwegian University of Science and Technology in Trondheim. Despite much evidence that getting lots of physical activity bodes well for long-term health, when its physical labour on the job, the opposite might be true.During leisure time, for example, people might jog for a half hour or so, enough time to increase their heart rate and build stronger bones and muscles."I think that people with physically demanding jobs should exercise outside the workplace to improve their cardiorespiratory fitness and muscular strength," Moholdt, who wasn’t involved in the study, said. "We’ve known for a while already that physically demanding work can be bad for you," said lead study author Pieter Coenen, an occupational health researcher at VU University Medical Center in Amsterdam.But in some jobs, physical activity can be nonstop for eight hours straight with few breaks, and this can take a toll on health over time, leading to chronic issues like back pain and straining the cardiovascular system, Coenen said.Researchers found that men whose jobs involve a lot of physical labour are 18 per cent more likely to die prematurely than workers who sit at desks most of the day. "We think that physical activity at work and during leisure time are two really different kind of exercises with different physiological responses and health sheet metal outcomes as a result," Coenen said."."I am not sure the authors were able to completely exclude the effect of low socioeconomic status (and their associated risk factors) of manual workers," Stringhini, who wasn’t involved in the study, said. " This will reduce the relative exertion they experience during working hours. "On top of that, we know that people who are physically active at work, typically aren’t so active during leisure time, so these people are exposed to the negative health consequences of occupational physical activity and also benefit only to a limited extent from the positive health effects of leisure-time physical activity. Women who did manual labour appeared to live longer than women who didn’t, although the difference was too small to rule out the possibility that it was due to chance.While the study wasn’t a controlled experiment designed to prove how activity levels at work might directly affect longevity, the results suggest there’s something inherently different about manual labour and leisure-time exercise, Coenen added.It might sound counterintuitive, but the key to longevity for manual labourers might lie in getting lots of exercise outside of work hours, said Dr.The analysis looked at data from 17 previous studies examining the link between longevity and activity levels at work, including a total of 193,696 adults followed for an average of almost 20 years. |
06.01.2022., četvrtak
The children have been made to sit
|
The children have been made to sit.Nobody will be allowed to hatch conspiracy against India while living in India, he added. It has reassured people that the new law does not take anyones citizenship."Those who do not know what the CAA is are staging sit-ins. The Hindus, Sikhs, Buddhists, Jains and Parsis are not important. It is shameful," he said..He said that protesting peacefully is everyone’s right but if a person damages public property, "we will recover the damage caused from that persons property and will punish them so that the next generation remembers it. And they have said the protests will continue against the CAA until the ISI agents are given entry into India," he alleged, adding, "This is a shameful statement made by Congress leaders". The UP government issued notices to the protesters, seeking compensation for the damage they caused to the public property. Its such a big crime that the men are sleeping under the quilt and Sit-stand desks for sale the women are made to sit at roads. If you go and ask anyone why are they sitting on ‘dharna’, they will say the men of the house feel that they have become so incompetent that they cannot do anything, so they want the women to go and sit on ‘dharna’. They know if they indulge in vandalism, their property will be seized. Now, for the Congress, even the Christians are not important.On Wednesday, Mr Adityanath also accused the Congress, the Samajwadi Party and the Left parties of doing politics at the cost of the nation.Some of the protests turned violent in Uttar Pradesh last month in which about 20 people died and the Adityanath government cracked down on those who indulged in arson.""I would like to say from the soil of India, and especially from the soil of Uttar Pradesh, that if pro-azadi slogans are raised here in the name of protests, like there used to be in Kashmir, then it will come in the category of sedition and stringent action will be taken by the government," Mr Adityanath said.Kanpur: Uttar Pradesh chief minister Yogi Adityanath on Wednesday criticised the ongoing protests against the new citizenship law, saying that it was "shameful" that the men sitting in the comfort of their homes had sent the women and children out on the streets to agitate. The central government has defended the law, saying it grants citizenship to religious minorities escaping persecution in Pakistan, Bangladesh and Afghanistan and who have come to India by December 31, 2014."For them, the country is not important.Addressing a rally in support of the Citizenship (Amendment) Act in Kanpur, Mr Adityanath said, "These people do not have courage to participate in the protests themselves.At several places, including in Delhis Shaheen Bagh and in Lucknow, women have been leading the protest against the law, alleging it is discriminatory and fearing it targets the Muslim community. Now what have they done?"They started making the women sit at roads. |
16.12.2021., četvrtak
They plotted his murder meticulously and executed
|
"They knocked on the door of the victim’s house, as soon as it opened, Miskin barged in and shot the litterateur twice in the head, killing him on the spot, the SIT chargesheet stated.M.Dr Kalburgi became their ‘Durjan’ (enemy) after he attended a discussion on "Karnataka Prevention of Superstitious Practice Bill 2013" at Vigyan Bhavan in Bengaluru.They assumed different nicknames and used mobile phones not registered in their names for their activities, the SIT stated. Miskin aka Xerox (27) custom Sit-stand desks for sale was a resident of Chaitanya Nagar in Hubballi.All the six accused were members of an anonymous organisation and were inspired by ‘Kshatra Dharma Sadhana’, a book published by Sanatan Sanstha. They plotted his murder meticulously and executed him at his home in Kalyan Nagar in Dharwad on August 30, 2015.The SIT also named five others as accused in the case, Amol Kale aka Bhaisab (37) of Chinchwad in Pune, Praveen Prakash Chatur aka Masalevala (26) of Shahpura in Belagavi, Vasudev Bhagavan Suryavamshi aka Mechanic (29) of Sakali village in Jalgaon, Sharad Kalaskar aka Chhote (25) of Keshapuri village in Aurangabad and Amith Ramachandra Baddi (27) of Rani Chennamma Circle in Hubballi. Kalburgi on August 30, 2015, stated the Special Investigation Team (SIT), which filed a chargesheet in the case before the district court of Hubballi-Dharwad on Saturday..Leading up to Dr Kalburgi’s assassination, the accused trained in firearms in different parts of Karnataka and Maharasthra, and were in constant touch with each other, hatching plots to murder those against the Hindutva ideology.Bengaluru: Ganesh Miskin, the hitman allegedly involved in the killing of journalist Gauri Lankesh, had also shot dead litterateur and researcher Dr M.The radical right-wing organisation identified and recruited people with a history of aggression and violence or those with criminal backgrounds. |
08.12.2021., srijeda
The alleged incident had taken place in presence
|
Another accused in the Dabholkar case, Sachin Andure, who is judicial custody and lodged in Punes Yerwada Jail, also claimed the same SIT officer had brutally assaulted him when he was in the CBIs custody, Punalekar said. "When we talked to Kale, he, too, revealed he was subjected to assault by the official," Punalekar claimed. Bangera, during his production, told a Pune court Monday that he was assaulted by a police official while he was in the CBIs custody, Punalekar said. The SP-level official of the Maharashtra police SIT allegedly assaulted the duo. He said his organisation has written to Prime Minister, Maharashtra Chief Minister and Union Home Minister about the incident and demanded a probe. Police believe the killing of Dabholkar at Pune in 2013 and of Pansare at Kolhapur in 2015 are linked. He threatened them and said if they dont confess their role in the Pansare murder case they would face "worse torture" when the SIT takes their custody, Punalekar said. The HVP calls itself a "voluntary organisation of nationalist and devout Hindu advocates". Punalekar demanded that the officers be subjected to narco test to bring out the truth. Both the officers claimed they had the "blessings" of higher authorities, he said. The alleged incident had taken place in presence of a CBI officer, who, too assaulted Andure, he said. The CBI is probing the Dabholkar case, while the state police are looking into Pansares killing.. Bangera was later remanded in judicial custody by the court.Mumbai: An SIT official, probing the killing of Communist leader Govind Pansare, allegedly "assaulted and threatened" two accused arrested for the killing of rationalist Narendra Dabholkar when they were in the CBIs custody, a right-wing outfit claimed Tuesday. "Following which we gave a written application to the court about the incident and the matter is slated for hearing of September 14," he added. Sanjiv Punalekar, an advocate and secretary of the Hindu Vidhidnya Parishad (HVP), made this allegation while addressing a press conference here. The alleged incident took place on September custom steel bushing for sale 8, when the two accused in the Dabholkar case. |
23.11.2021., utorak
Kale had allegedly recruited
|
However, he was still involved in their activities, especially in "talent spotting"."Kale had allegedly recruited Wagmare to kill Gauri and had trained him in shooting. K.Wagmare along with five other accused has been arrested for their alleged involvement in Lankesh’s murder on September 5 last year and conspiracy to kill writer Prof.M.An unprepared Kale, who had been maintaining a stoic silence before the SIT, was reportedly taken aback when he saw Wagmare, said a source. Naveen alias Hotte Manja on March 2 for allegedly providing logistical support to Gauri killers was the first breakthrough in the case.Wagmare has allegedly confessed to his crime and told investigators that he was tasked for the "ideological" killing by Pune-based engineer Amol Kale.Parshuram Ashok Wagmare alias Parashu, 26, a serial offender from Sindhagi in Karnataka’s Vijayapura district, was taken to Lankesh’s house in Bengaluru on a bike by the killer of Kalburgi, police sources said on Friday. How and why did he get involved in an alleged ideological murder needs to be investigated," said the source. According to the SIT, Kale had strategically distanced himself from the right wing outfit after the 2008 Malegaon blast to avoid.According to sources, Amit Degwekar, a resident of an ashram in Sindhudurg in Maharashtra who is also under arrest in the Gauri murder, is another person to be questioned, police said.. He is on the run, but we should get him soon," said a police source.Kale, who is also under arrest for Lankesh’s killing, is a former convener of the Hindu Janajagruti Samiti (HJS) which is an affiliate of right wing outfit Sanathan Sanstha in Ponda, South Goa. This was Wagmare’s first murder," said the officer."He shouted and banged his head on a wall when he saw Wagmare, who was also in police custody along with him and other accused," he said.S. Bhagwan. Kalburgi’s killer."When Kale saw Wagmare, he knew that the latter would have spilled the beans to the SIT," said the source.He was arrested along with Kale and Manohar Edave of Vijayapura district in the third week of May for their stainless steel bushings alleged involvement in the conspiracy to kill Prof."Wagmare rode pillion to a man who is Prof.To confirm Wagmare’s confession, the SIT arranged a "strategic" chance encounter between him and Kale on Wednesday night, a day before they were produced in a local court. |
11.11.2021., četvrtak
If the incident is confirmed
|
"SDM Kullu, Sunny Sharma, will hold the magisterial inquiry."Dalit students were made to sit in a place used for keeping horses," they said. But that’s not enough. I have asked Secretary, Education to get a report and take stern action," said State Education Minister Suresh Bhardwaj.A report in The Indian Express said that some of the students made a complaint to Kullu Deputy Commissioner Yunus on Friday evening, alleging that a teacher, Mehar Chand, told them to sit outside the room where the television had been set up and warned against leaving midway.Shimla: In an act of caste discrimination, a government-run high school in Kullu reportedly made its Dalit students sit separately in a "place used for horses" during the telecast of Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s ‘Pariksha par Charcha’ speech on Friday. The report has been sought in the next two days," he said, adding that "Disciplinary action has already been initiated against the headmaster.Following a purported video clip of the incident, a local organisation, Anusuchit Jati Kalyan Sangh, lodged a protest with the school headmaster, Rajan Bhardwaj, and deputy director, education, Kullu, Jagdish Pathania, on Saturday, the report further said. If the incident is confirmed, criminal liability will be fixed," he said."I have also been told that Dalit students faced discrimination in the school earlier too, during midday meals."Students belonging to Scheduled Caste category are made to sit separately. If these reports are true, we will not spare the guilty," he further added.According to reports, the incident took place in Kullu’s Chestha gram panchayat, where the school had made arrangements custom metal desks for students to watch Prime Minister’s televised programme at the residence of the head of the school management committee.""This matter has come to my notice today.The deputy commissioner termed it as a "serious matter" and said a magisterial probe has been ordered into the incident."The government will seek a report from the local administration and recommend suitable action," said Secretary (Education) Arun Sharma. Even the headmaster does nothing… he also practices untouchability," they said..A member of the group said, "The headmaster, Rajan Bhardwaj, has confirmed the incident and tendered an apology, assuring that this will not be allowed to happen again. |
20.10.2021., srijeda
A few tested dextrose solutions
|
Participants reported improvements in pain, function and range of motion with prolotherapy and also reported high levels of satisfaction with the treatment. Regina Sit, a researcher at the Chinese University of Hong Kong who wasn’t involved in the study.Eight of the 10 studies were of poor quality, researchers concluded."Studies are needed to conclude which injection therapy should be given higher priority in routine clinical care," Sit added. But the evidence on the effectiveness of prolotherapy isn’t strong enough to recommend it until after other treatments fail, said senior study author Dr."Conservative therapies such exercises, physical therapy, oral analgesic medications and complementary therapies such as acupuncture and herbal treatment have marginal effectiveness," Sit said by email.Knee osteoarthritis, a leading cause of pain and disability in older adults, occurs when flexible tissue at the ends of bones wears down.But these small studies had such different designs and patient populations that it wasn’t possible to do a pooled analysis of all data from all the studies to determine if there was a meaningful benefit in a larger group of people, researchers report in the British Medical Bulletin. A few tested dextrose solutions that also contained anesthetics like lidocaine or ropivacaine. Clinicians might inject corticosteroids or hyaluronic acid, which is similar to a lubricant found naturally in joints.Across all of the studies that Maffulli and colleagues reviewed, most tested injections containing dextrose (a sugar), and two combined dextrose and sodium. Prolotherapy involves injecting a solution of natural irritants like sugar or sodium next to the site where soft tissue like ligaments, tendons or muscle were injured or tore away from the bone.None of the studies reported dangerous side effects from prolotherapy, and the researchers note that the solutions injected may not cost much or be difficult to administer.While it’s possible steel suppliers prolotherapy may be safe and effective, research to date doesn’t offer a clear picture of how this option stacks up against other types of injections for knee osteoarthritis, Sit said.Researchers examined data from 10 previous studies of what’s known as prolotherapy, which is often used for chronic back pain. Most studies didn’t report what’s known as an effect size, or how much more pain relief people got from prolotherapy than from no treatment or from other interventions.The trouble with knee osteoarthritis is that evidence is mixed for other options, too, said Dr.Results from these studies, which had a total of 529 patients, suggest that prolotherapy may be a safe way to help ease pain from knee osteoarthritis.An alternative medicine approach to joint pain that typically uses injections of sugar or sodium may be worth trying for knee osteoarthritis after traditional approaches fail, a recent review suggests."There is no evidence that prolotherapy should be tried as a first line therapy," Maffulli said by email. Joint injections are a common approach for this type of pain, Sit added. Nicola Maffulli of the University of Salerno in Italy.. "It should always be part of a holistic management plan, with weight reduction, activity changes, and physiotherapy."Ideal patients for prolotherapy might include people with mild to moderate knee osteoarthritis who don’t get relief from medication or physical therapy, Maffulli added. While it can’t be cured, physical therapy or anti-inflammatory medications are often prescribed to relieve pain and improve mobility. |
13.10.2021., srijeda
The shopkeepers were criticising us every day
|
Aao, kitna dum hai tumhari jailon mein, aao, bharo," she said. As is the allegiance to India, its tiranga, its Constitution. custom metal desks "They said they didn’t have enough female constables," both Sharjeel and Aasif told me separately.A law student, Ehtmam, told me, "The December 13 police attack on Jamia students upset them greatly, especially the women.There was an unsaid rule now, about not revealing the organisers, and not putting a face or a name to the movement.Several showrooms on Road No.He is talking of a dharna, a chakka jaam. Elections were about to be announced and polarisation will help the BJP."There was talk of Delhi elections ke pehle saza de denge, vardaat ho jayegi," Sharjeel recalled. Most put it down to women being more upset by the attack on Jamia students, especially girls."On January 2, I was walking and thinking, if we don’t have an exit plan, hum akele pad jayenge."Tum ko peacefully uthane se mana kar diya hai," the officer had said to them, disclosing the instructions received from the Union Home Ministry.On January 28, Sharjeel was arrested, the same day when, in a video that went viral, Anurag Thakur, Union minister of state for finance, is seen prompting a crowd at an election rally. We are afraid that the BJP wants violence by not bringing in the police. But people, especially women, were in no mood to leave.An ‘exit plan’ was worked out with at least three senior police officials, including one from the local thana..Locally, however, the dharna was causing inconvenience to a lot of people. "The Congress has not been secular. " The shopkeepers were criticising us every day, saying ‘60-70 lakh ka stock credit pe liya hua hai, staff bhi garib hai. Anyone can start a scuffle… 10-20 men dressed as Muslims.", he says, to which the crowd responds "."Maine socha tha ki hamare Wazir-e-Azam hain, awam ke badshah hain, Pradhan Mantri hain, woh hamari takleef samjhenge.Early portentsEven on December 15, when an anti-CAA protest at Shaheen Bagh began to turn into a sit-in, Sharjeel and Aasif had got a glimpse of how quickly and easily things could go wrong. So the best option was to dislodge the protesters nicely, peacefully… promotion bhi mil jayega," Sharjeel said. During that night, 10-15 young men blocked both sides of the road again.Attacking women, especially Muslim women, after the BJP had made triple talaq a poll plank in Delhi elections, was not going to fly."Women had come and gone. 13A. Either they themselves, or someone in their family or a neighbour had studied or worked there."Since Jamia, the police were on the back-foot." He also wrote of money being used to taint the movement.From that moment, Sharjeel, "the Gandhi of Shaheen Bagh", became a "traitor, gaddar," accused of having taken "Rs1-2 crore from Amit Shah". It was discussed over and over. Jo karna hai karne do," is what the cops said they had been told. A day later a survey predicted that the ruling Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) was all set to sweep back to power in Delhi with 59 of the 70 seats.30 am.Police fired rubber bullets and Sharjeel left after 10 pm to go to Aasif’s home in Shaheen Bagh. Bachche uthaye jayenge.But on the night of January 1, the cops changed their tune. "There was a Congress lobby versus a BJP lobby and we didn’t want to become players in it or its victims. Not an armed rebellion. It is difficult to target mothers, grandmothers and turn them into hate figures.The owners of the buildings on the main road, where shops and showrooms had been shut since December 15, decided that no rent will be charged for the duration of the protest. Only then will we, they be heard. At around 8.The five-minute clip played on a loop on certain TV channels with the hashtag #tukdetukdegang. Woh aaj tak aa kar yeh pooch bhi na sake ki kya pareshani hai?" she said. This led 17-year-old Rambhakt Gopal to post "Shaheen Bagh, khel khatam" on his Facebook page before shooting at Jamia Millia Islamia’s anti-CAA protesters. Two more such shootings followed in the next few days. I spoke for an hour about why we must not pick up stones," Sharjeel told me."Tarannum baajiTarannum Begum from Batla House, Okhla, is a widow and mother of three and has been sitting in protest at Shaheen Bagh since December 15..As temperatures dipped and chai kept brewing night and day, the nearby Warda Hospital kept its bathrooms open for women protesters and visitors. Volunteers set up a library for children whose mothers were sitting in protest."Aasif Mujtaba said, "You can’t win over a state by throwing stones,"..In antakshari style, they are raising slogans and at one point they start chanting, "BJP ho barbaad, ho barbaad, ho barbaad".On a good day, the 17 km-long drive from 7, Lok Kalyan Marg to Shaheen Bagh takes about 37 minutes. The Congress was not really in play.Sharjeel Imam’s politics is that of a strident scholar. Further away a group of school-going girls are sitting in a circle, white strips tied around their foreheads on which they have scribbled with pen, "No CAA, No NRC".Protest etiquetteIt is late. Like the Crocs he wore under his kurta-pyjama, the ensemble didn’t gel.Women leading the protest also posed a dilemma for the BJP government. And on February 2, a shot was fired at Jamia’s Gate No. The police agreed," Sharjeel said. People rushed back to the street and many of them started pelting stones," Sharjeel recalled to me."Unki nagrikta kaun dega? Unke maa-baap kahan se dhoond ke laye jayenge? Woh Dada-Dadi, Nana-Nani kahan se layenge?"she says. We were very clear and had said New Year tak baithenge, New Year ke baad, agar uthana hai, toh kaise uthayenge… Bring lots of women constables and remove the protesting women, open the blockade on both sides of Road No. The matter was now being handled by the Union Home Ministry and the instructions were "not to intervene". I sat on the stage and said remove it," Sharjeel said.Everyone I spoke with, to try and understand how and when had women become the main protesters, gave vague answers.Sharjeel Imam, from Delhi Public School, Vasant Vihar, who had not just studied but also taught at IIT Mumbai, would not make the cut.If they could, they would have discussed an ominous remark of the police officer on the freezing night of January 1.The next day, junior finance minister Anurag Thakur followed up Shah’s instructions by inciting people to chant "goli maro gaddaraon ko"."We said no cash, give kambal, chai patti, cheeni, but no cash… That could even lead to NSA (National Security Act)… And then one day, a donation box appeared. "We have to write our own history.Men and women sitting together day and night is not an acceptable scenario in any Indian residential colony. "That is the only way to be heard. While addressing a pro-citizenship law rally in Kanpur, he asked why the men of Shaheen Bagh were "sleeping under the quilt while women have been pushed forward". 13A."There was anger, and the December 15 protest gave it a conduit to well up.. There was also concern that men could be removed forcibly and detained at any time, most likely in the dead of night. Then the police will get a chance to enter the mohalla..If they’d listen, Sharjeel’s beliefs would warm the cockles of saffron hearts."Tum ko peacefully uthane se mana kar diya hai… court bhi intervene nahin karega," Sharjeel recalled a police officer telling him. Your blockade has shut our businesses but we have to pay staff salaries, we have to pay rent’," Aasif recalled. But in a style that exudes a scholar’s intellectual confidence and an activist’s moral certitude, he routinely dismisses some well-regarded Muslim historians, takes a strong position against not just the Congress and the Left, but also his college mate Kanhaiya Kumar who, he says, is a pointless public attraction that gathers huge crowds but changes nothing."He mentions the Chicken’s Neck, the narrow strip of land that connects the Northeast with the rest of India, being Muslim dominated and says that if 5 lakh Muslims were to mobilise, they could hamper the Army’s movement and supply. Though one side of the barricaded road was kept free for ambulances and school buses to pass, all other traffic between Kalindi Kunj and Noida was diverted, leading to long, harrowing jams.Sharjeel and Aasif, encircled by about 300 men, took turns to explain why it was important to protest.It’s at about 30 minutes into the speech that we come to the five minutes where he talks of Assam: "If 5 lakh people come together and sit in dharna, they can cut off Assam from the rest of India at least for a month or two. Especially women who have been abandoned by their families, husbands, and widows. The BJP, a distant second, was tipped to get eight seats, an embarrassing increase of just five from its 2015 tally. Almost every day, till the 1st of January.Shaheen Bagh’s two lakh residents, living about a kilometre away from Jamia, are deeply connected with the university. Some said that they were inspired by Ayesha Renna, Ladeeda Farzana and Shaheen Abdullah — the three hijab-clad girls who had shielded a male student from police beating. Next to the stage, some elderly women are offering namaz. Hum Samvidhan ke liye, Hindustan ke liye, apne hak ke liye lad rahe hain. Even our Constitution is not secular — only a Hindu can be a Dalit as per the 1950 presidential order, not a Muslim or a Christian," he says often in his speeches."I hardly spoke against the BJP at Shaheen Bagh," he said. Aur violently uthane ke liye sabse achcha hai ki isko pura communal colour de dein — Shaheen Bagh ka jo face hai, peaceful protest ka, woh khatam ho jaye," Aasif said.One of the older ladies comes and scolds the girls: "Criticise NRC, CAA all you want.The AAP’s best bet was to keep the election campaign, the narrative focussed on local issues — pani, bijli, sadak, health clinics, but the BJP needed a mudda, and for this it needed an enemy with a face. 13A remained shut. "All we can do is disrupt," said Sharjeel.On January 29, a news report said the BJP’s fortunes in Delhi Assembly elections are on an upswing, and an internal poll was predicting at least 30-35 of the 70 seats in Delhi. Around 3.The well-spring of angerIn Jamia Nagar and Shaheen Bagh, disquiet over the Citizenship (Amendment) Act passed by Parliament on December 11 turned into indignation when, two days later, police entered Jamia Millia Islamia University and beat up students.In the Prime Minister’s cavalcade, which moves at 120 km per hour, that distance would take a little over 10 minutes. The sense of safety they once felt when their sons and daughters were in college was now gone.He understood.NEW DELHI: This is the story of how the Delhi Police scuttled an agreed plan to peacefully dislodge the Shaheen Bagh protesters on the instructions of the Union Home Ministry so that it became an election ‘mudda’ for the BJP.Delhi polls announced On January 6, the Election Commission announced that polling in Delhi will take place on February 8 and votes will be counted on February 11.. But they were like ke, ‘Nahin, hum nahin hatenge… We’ve been sitting here for 17-18 days but haven’t got the result we wanted, so why should we leave?’ We could not convince people," Humera said."As soon as the barricades were removed from one side of the road, one protester, carrying the Tricolour, started throwing stones at passing vehicles..Sharjeel, a BTech and MTech in computer science from IIT Mumbai, is now a student of history pursuing his PhD in JNU. They would have been unnerved."It was like a scene from Mumbai locals. After sensitisation, there must be a plan of action. So we formed a committee. A small 24x7 health camp with doctors came up."It is out of our hands""On the 31st and 1st night there was a huge crowd," recalled Aasif, suggesting that the sit-in protest had been successful in highlighting the communal, divisive nature of the CAA nationally and internationally and it was now time to move out of Shaheen Bagh. And Shaheen Bagh mein ghusenge toh policewale bhi zaroor mare jayenge."More than a dharnaShaheen Bagh was becoming the powerful pivot of the anti-CAA movement.‘Hum nahin hatenge’Humera, a resident of Shaheen Bagh and a student of zoology, had been managing the stage all these days.But a JNU scholar with a bushy beard who spoke of cutting off Assam from the rest of the country did. And I am sitting talking to Upasna from Bijnor in the enclosure around the Shaheen Bagh stage. Jaise ma-baap apne bachche ki sunte hain, vaise woh hamari sunenge. Jisko jana hai woh jayein’," Sharjeel recalled to me.."Keh rahe hai ki agar Modiji ne kaha hai ki woh ek inch nahin hatenge, toh hum ek millimetre bhi peeche nahin hatenge."People have vested interests," Sharjeel said during one of our conversations.Sharjeel, more than Aasif, was mindful of the threat of violence and the possibility of the Shaheen Bagh protest becoming politicised and sabotaged. But it was increasing for the BJP," Sharjeel said."Delhi kyun band karna hai — Delhi band karna hai kyunki awam ko takleef ho," he says and adds that while protesting, people must guard against violence, sabotage and political takeover.. The longer the women stayed, Shaheen Bagh’s attraction and popularity increased, as did the cooperation and sacrifice of those working behind the scenes, or just quietly supporting the protest."Na hamari Modiji se ladai hai, na Amit Shahji se. Some homes remained open too, offering beds and washrooms.Shaheen Bagh’s moral force kept growing."Maine kaha, aap peacefully nahin uthayenge toh hum baithe rahenge.On January 24, Union minister Prakash Javadekar, speaking at an election rally, asked Delhi voters to decide whether they wanted "Jinnah wali azaadi or Jai Mata Di"...Sharjeel’s hour-long speech, delivered on January 16 on the footpath outside AMU, was no different. But don’t be badtameez, don’t be rude.He spoke approvingly of constitutional spirit, but said the Constitution is not secular.Sharjeel and AasifSharjeel Imam and Aasif Mujtaba had only met for the first time on December 14, during an anti-CAA protest at Jamia. "There was constant fear of violence — we were conscious of it 24x7.They would have liked to discuss it, except that Sharjeel was in police custody and Aasif remains besieged by the recurring shootings at Shaheen Bagh and Jamia Millia Islamia University.The women of Shaheen Bagh would not do and that lament was clear in Yogi Adityanath’s comment on January 22. She worries similarly for orphans.If Mr Modi were to come, he will see tirangas painted on faces, fluttering in small hands, on the barricades, on the stage, on every bamboo stick and pole in sight, and he will hear both — a wail and a warning."This delicate etiquette is implemented and observed diligently by the women protesters of Shaheen Bagh. When I first texted her on January 14, she couldn’t talk as she had lost her voice anchoring and giving speeches.A map of India in circulation on social media shows the sites of at least 40 Shaheen Bagh-like protests that have come up across the country."Is mein hamara kya fayeda hoga? Nahin uthana.But there were several practical reasons behind this brilliant idea.Sharjeel and Aasif asked the protesters to vacate the protest site.He had a mike in his hand and kept shouting, "Stop the violence, don’t vandalise property. They were distributing pamphlets and delivering speeches in which they asked people to organise themselves, to block roads. 5.So on the fifth day of the protest, eight CCTV cameras were installed in and around the tent. He nitpicks and is critical of all. I agreed, though I was not very happy...As days progressed and new challenges came up, several sub-committees were formed..In between the sloganeering, singing and speeches, Sharjeel repeatedly spurned cash donations that people were offering. He discussed the Poona Pact, called Mahatma Gandhi a "fascist", criticised the Congress, talked of the history of violence of the Left and Right, and said Indian history had been written by pandits. If violence happens, we will be held responsible," said Sharjeel, whose PhD is on Hindu-Muslim riots. At one point, Sharjeel recalled, there was a theological discussion over what Prophet Mohammed had said — that ‘Kisi ka rasta band karna sunnat ke khilaf hai’."There was now marginal utility of the protest and the roadblock, and it was further reducing for us.The story begins several weeks before Union home minister Amit Shah, at an election rally in Delhi on January 27, goaded his audience to "press the voting button so hard that the tremors are felt in Shaheen Bagh". Footage was relayed to a backend office.On January 2, Sharjeel put out a statement: "We have taken back the chakka jaam of Shaheen Bagh Road to avoid violence and attempt by goons to politicise the movement. 13A, which links Mathura Road and Kalindi Kunj to Noida, had been blocked with cement slabs, stones and police barricades.By December 16, the day after the early protesters were hemmed in and stones were thrown, a mike had materialised and a makeshift stage was organised by some local Congress leaders on Road No."The point was to tell them that the Congress is not your sympathiser… If the Congress was so concerned about the CAA and the NRC, they could have blocked Delhi on their own."Toh peacefully nahin uthane ka matlab hai ki they wanted isko violently uthayen. Except Delhi, all were states with BJP governments. People can walk," Sharjeel said. It was more than just a peaceful dharna — it was a moral force field whose ripples were being felt not just on Raisina Hill, but across the country."I said, ‘Hamein baithna hai, hum baithenge. Sitting at Jantar Mantar, even for years, will yield nothing."Hum jeet gaye toh desh mubarak, hum mar gaye toh kafan mubarak," says Tarannum baaji.Though the message that Sharjeel, Aasif and others had drilled in — not to trust any political party — stayed, the sound and optics changed.Since the first week of December, Sharjeel Imam and many other students of JNU, Aligarh Muslim University, Jamia had been actively engaged in educating people about CAA and NRC. Phir directly mujhse hi bola, ‘Main dobara bol raha hoon, ki hum peacefully nahin uthayenge’," Aasif said.goli maaro saalon ko".The Delhi Police forcibly entering a Muslim neighbourhood was not a scenario anyone wanted. Aasif didn’t.One of the main reasons for the change, according to two unnamed leaders, was the rising resentment against the sit-in protest at Shaheen Bagh. They would have recalled the "exit plan" they had negotiated with the Delhi Police and were ready to implement after the New Year. Humera said that the women and other protesters are worried, but in no mood to move.Someone sent biryani, someone brought boiled eggs, and someone sent helmets for protection in case of a police attack. He said let’s get up now and organise a peaceful march to Amit Shah’s house next Friday.Artists from across the country came to create pieces of protest art — A mock detention centre in which people stand behind bars and pose for pictures.On January 25, a five-minute clip of Sharjeel’s speech went viral and Assam police filed a case against him. Aasif, a resident of Shaheen Bagh, who did his BTech and MTech in environmental engineering from IIT Delhi, is pursuing his PhD from IIT.30 pm, police came and asked us to vacate at least one side of the road. Someone who was easy to identify, by his clothes, speech, college.A week after Yogi Adityanath called for all those chanting the "azaadi" slogan to be charged with sedition, Rambhakt Gopal aimed a gun at anti-CAA protesters in Jamia and said, "Ye lo azaadi. The Shaheen Bagh protest had been forcibly given a face and attacking it now became easy.He was accused of sedition, provocation with the intent to cause riots."Sharjeel, Aasif and other members of the Shaheen Bagh committee had regular meetings with the police, often at night, near the police barricade, at a distance of about 100 metres from the protest tent. She says she has gone home only eight times.A man was needed — someone who would naturally fit the anti-national template created by the BJP. It also looked unapologetically Islamic, organic.I met her a few days later.. Don’t insult anyone.."The 12-member Shaheen Bagh Coordination Committee was focused on creating a safe space for people to sit in peaceful protest and use the stage for students, scholars and experts to talk about CAA, NRC, citizen’s rights, the Constitution and the law. Barely an hour later, by around 5 pm, both sides of Road No."It is out of our hands," the cops said.Women take overAs Sharjeel and Aasif stepped back and others took charge, the character of the Shaheen Bagh protest changed.Two people would have seen this chain of events coming: Sharjeel Imam and Aasif Mujtaba, the two IITians who led the protest at Shaheen Bagh. At around 4 pm, when a crowd in Jamia Nagar lifted Sharjeel on their shoulders and asked, "Hamein kya karna chahiye?", his two-word response, "Chakka Jaam". "I returned, at around 7 am the next day, and a crowd was sitting."We had been negotiating with the police."The police were also saying, ab tum hato, khali karo, bahut ho gaya."Article 370 par, Kashmir par, Ayodhya judgment par, hum sab ne sarkar ki izzat rakhi… Sarkar kehti hai ki triple talaq se woh Muslim women ko protect karna chahte hain, toh un auraton ko protect karna nahin chahti jo Shaheen Bagh mein baithi hain?"On February 1, another gun-wielding man was arrested after he fired in the air near the Shaheen Bagh protest site."We said, hum kisi ka rasta nahin rok rahein, hum sadak band kar rahe hain. An upright map of India next to a mini India Gate with the names of all those who died in anti-CAA protests. The plan was to keep the protest going for some days, then call off the blockade and carry forward the movement in some other form. We tried to explain to people that we should move."In conversations with me that began on January 16, he recalled, "We were talking of blocking both sides of the highway, of disrupting the water and milk supply to Delhi."Tarannum baaji, as she is called, talks of the difficulty many women are going to face when asked for proof of their residence and ancestors. "Desh ke gaddaron ko."While speaking of people’s anger against CAA and NRC, he said students, scholars should take charge and channel it productively, for an outcome. Women, on the other hand, can only be arrested by women cops, and never after sunset or before sunrise.."The local AAP MLA, Amanatullah Khan, had not been so keen. Several other states followed suit.The Shaheen Bagh protest now sounded less scholarly, more participative.Tarannum baaji says she has no choice but to protest, to save herself and her children from discrimination, harassment and being sent to detention centres. Many were leaning towards Hong Kong-style flash mobs blocking roads, when they wanted, where they wanted. |
